JapanForum.com  


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
(#1 (permalink))
Old
manganimefan227's Avatar
manganimefan227 (Offline)
星の翼
 
Posts: 986
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: In a Starry Night with Fire flies
Memorizing radicals before Kanji - 08-11-2011, 01:43 PM

Does this method work? Has anyone tried it? Does memorizing all of the radicals really boost how fast you pick up kanji? Are there any good websites for this?

Thank you for your time!


My Life Sucks- The kids I babysit have drooled, ripped or drawn on all of the cards and put the cars with the little people in the microwave!

I have no Friends- The cats have scratched and destroyed all of the DVDs!

I always owe someone- In fact I put two os in it!

I always ruin my clothes with Bleach!- The show is so dom suspensful I spill my grape soda on them!

But . . .I'll live.
Reply With Quote
(#2 (permalink))
Old
ryuurui's Avatar
ryuurui (Offline)
Japanese calligrapher
 
Posts: 880
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Tokyo
08-11-2011, 02:36 PM

I would not recommend it. Simply because the forms of kanji, hence the types of radicals that "build" them, underwent many modifications and changes throughout the history of evolution of Chinese characters. Also, 85% of the characters are semasio-phonetics, so it will only confuse you. If anything, I would suggest learning major radicals while studying characters. For instance, a presence of 草冠 ("grass crown", i.e. grass radical) on top (crown) of the character usually leads to a conclusion that given character is associated with plants, etc.

Last edited by ryuurui : 08-11-2011 at 07:34 PM.
Reply With Quote
(#3 (permalink))
Old
delacroix01's Avatar
delacroix01 (Offline)
JF Old Timer
 
Posts: 252
Join Date: Apr 2009
08-12-2011, 09:35 AM

^
^
If your first language is outside the Eastern Asian language system, I think it's best to just pick up new words whenever you read something and memorize them eventually, rather than trying to learn radicals or separate kanji at a time. I have never tried to learn radicals so far, and my vocabulary is still being built at a pace that I feel comfortable. The method of learning separate kanji does work for me, though. My first language has many words originated from Chinese, rendering me possible of understanding certain new words (not all of them, of course) just by remembering the kanji forming those words. I believe Chinese and Korean people have even greater advantage since their languages are closer to Japanese, not just the similarity in word-sounding.

Last edited by delacroix01 : 08-12-2011 at 09:42 AM.
Reply With Quote
(#4 (permalink))
Old
Nyororin's Avatar
Nyororin (Offline)
Mod Extraordinaire
 
Posts: 4,147
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: あま市
Send a message via MSN to Nyororin Send a message via Yahoo to Nyororin
08-12-2011, 10:00 AM

I can`t see how this would be useful for anything other than writing... And even then, a pretty convoluted way to improve.

Most kanji are so far removed from the meaning implied by the radicals - if they haven`t been simplified and are now no longer using the original radicals at all - that it won`t be of much help with meaning. Occasionally, a radical can proivide a hint about the reading of the kanji, but again, it`s hit and miss as there are more that don`t take a hint from the radicals. With writing, I admit it will probably be a bit easier to write properly if you are familiar with the stroke order of the radicals (and later helpful with reading messy handwriting), but I don`t think it will really help you learn the kanji to begin with.


If anyone is trying to find me… Tamyuun on Instagram is probably the easiest.
Reply With Quote
(#5 (permalink))
Old
Lonthego (Offline)
JF Regular
 
Posts: 57
Join Date: Jul 2011
08-12-2011, 04:42 PM

Plus there's like 214 radicals..you memorize those there's no guarantee you'll still be able to read any kanji..but if you instead memorize ~214 kanji you'll be doing very well.
I know the advantage you're talking about by knowing the radicals, but that's also something you pick up passively as you learn more and more kanji, you don't necessarily need to go out of your way to learn the radicals one by one.


My Japan Blog (lots of pics and experiences of living in Japan..with some of Thailand too)
Latest Entry = Today's Journey (click)
Reply With Quote
(#6 (permalink))
Old
KyleGoetz's Avatar
KyleGoetz (Offline)
Attorney at Flaw
 
Posts: 2,965
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Texas
08-12-2011, 06:16 PM

Knowing certain parts of kanji often helped me with the reading of a kanji (but 99.9999% of the time not with the meaning—I think there was a single, solitary case where I was able to figure out a kanji's meaning by looking at radical+context, and that may have been in Chinese text, not Japanese) in my prep for learning all joyo kanji. That being said, these parts were rarely radicals; rather, they were the other parts of the kanji!

That being said, the patterns did not become useful until I was far more advanced than you are now. You'll just start noticing, at some point, that a lot of kanji with 票 in it have a reading like ヒョウ. 漂流 (drift) has a ヒョウ, 投票 (vote) has a ヒョウ, 標本 (specimen) has a ヒョウ, etc. On the other hand, none of the kanji (漂票標) are semantically related—one has to do with drifting or floating (but see its radical indicates a relationship with water), another with votes, and another with a symbol or sign.

Another set of examples like this is 苗 (ビョウ), which shows up in 猫恐怖 (I assume that is read びょうきょうふ and not ねこきょうふ, ailurophobia—fear of cats), 描写 (びょうしゃ) (depiction/description) 錨泊 (びょうはく) (anchorage), 苗圃 (seedbed, びょうほ). They all have the same sound, ビョウ, but unrelated meanings (猫描錨苗 meaning, respectively, "cat," "draw," "anchor," and "sapling").

I've found knowing one can help me remember the readings for the others. Or, at the least, it gives me an educated guess to start with.

When I was more intermediate, I spent a few hours a couple of times compiling every kanji in Japanese that has 青 in it with a separate radical to see how many I could learn to understand and pronounce. It basically turned into a waste of time.

It is better to learn kanji in context (which is why I so often recommend people buy the book(s) Kanji in Context and learn that way).

Last edited by KyleGoetz : 08-12-2011 at 06:27 PM.
Reply With Quote
(#7 (permalink))
Old
Nameless's Avatar
Nameless (Offline)
JF Old Timer
 
Posts: 120
Join Date: Feb 2011
08-12-2011, 11:45 PM

Ok, I feel an urge to ask, what's your opinion on James Heisig method? Because that's the one I've been using so far, and it teaches radicals first and then the kanji formed by the latter.

I've seen cases of people that have spend years learning the kanji... it's creepy.
Reply With Quote
(#8 (permalink))
Old
KyleGoetz's Avatar
KyleGoetz (Offline)
Attorney at Flaw
 
Posts: 2,965
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Texas
08-12-2011, 11:54 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nameless View Post
Ok, I feel an urge to ask, what's your opinion on James Heisig method? Because that's the one I've been using so far, and it teaches radicals first and then the kanji formed by the latter.

I've seen cases of people that have spend years learning the kanji... it's creepy.
1. I've heard only bad things. I have never met a person who said it was worthwhile. Well, I take that back: I have seen some beginners on JF say it is working for them. I have never seen an intermediate or advanced speaker say it does, though. Perhaps because the type of person who attains intermediate or advanced level tends to study at university, and I've never heard of a university using the Heisig method ever. (Personally, I recommend Kanji in Context—it worked for me as I progressed from intermediate to advanced kanji knowledge).

2. You realize native Japanese spend about ten years learning kanji before they know 2000, right? Grades 1–6 gets them a thousand, and then they have until college entrance exams to learn the other thousand, basically. Now, just like with us speaking English, they continue to learn kanji (as we learn words) throughout adulthood, forgetting some, learning others, depending on level of education and profession/specialty.

Regardless, I think it's very possible for an adult to learn all joyo kanji in four years with serious study. Few people can muster that level of dedication for four straight years, though. I, for example, could not.

Last edited by KyleGoetz : 08-13-2011 at 12:00 AM.
Reply With Quote
(#9 (permalink))
Old
Nameless's Avatar
Nameless (Offline)
JF Old Timer
 
Posts: 120
Join Date: Feb 2011
08-13-2011, 12:34 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by KyleGoetz View Post
1. I've heard only bad things. I have never met a person who said it was worthwhile. Well, I take that back: I have seen some beginners on JF say it is working for them. I have never seen an intermediate or advanced speaker say it does, though. Perhaps because the type of person who attains intermediate or advanced level tends to study at university, and I've never heard of a university using the Heisig method ever. (Personally, I recommend Kanji in Context—it worked for me as I progressed from intermediate to advanced kanji knowledge).

2. You realize native Japanese spend about ten years learning kanji before they know 2000, right? Grades 1–6 gets them a thousand, and then they have until college entrance exams to learn the other thousand, basically. Now, just like with us speaking English, they continue to learn kanji (as we learn words) throughout adulthood, forgetting some, learning others, depending on level of education and profession/specialty.

Regardless, I think it's very possible for an adult to learn all joyo kanji in four years with serious study. Few people can muster that level of dedication for four straight years, though. I, for example, could not.
With Heisig's method I've been able to master 700~ and I have been LAZY...
the only problem I've found is that it is repetitive... because all you do is kanji and more kanji... I need to re start and continue until I finish all of the joyo... it feels bad to lack motivation... for some reason...

Nevertheless, I've read grammar here and there and it was easier than I thought, are kanji really the hardest part of Japanese?
Reply With Quote
(#10 (permalink))
Old
Lonthego (Offline)
JF Regular
 
Posts: 57
Join Date: Jul 2011
08-13-2011, 01:29 AM

Quote:
Nevertheless, I've read grammar here and there and it was easier than I thought, are kanji really the hardest part of Japanese?
Unless you aren't good with grammar, it's the hardest part of reading and writing, yeah
Doesn't help you at all when it comes to speaking/listening though..so is it the hardest part of Japanese in general?? that all depends on the person and their strengths/weaknesses


My Japan Blog (lots of pics and experiences of living in Japan..with some of Thailand too)
Latest Entry = Today's Journey (click)
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On




Copyright 2003-2006 Virtual Japan.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6