JapanForum.com  


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
(#31 (permalink))
Old
Nyororin's Avatar
Nyororin (Offline)
Mod Extraordinaire
 
Posts: 4,147
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: あま市
Send a message via MSN to Nyororin Send a message via Yahoo to Nyororin
12-13-2010, 12:24 AM

I think that the issue of dating a foreigner is being confused with actually marrying one.

In terms of family reaction, there is a huge difference. Most people will react with interest, fascination, approval, or even admiration when it comes to having a dating relationship with a foreigner. Move on to talk of marriage and the tables turn VERY quickly.

When my husband and I were dating - there was never a single negative word from anyone. (The closest was a friend of his from high school who said something along the lines of "Why would a foreigner choose HIM?!?" but that certainly wasn`t negative in my direction...)
When we told everyone our intent to marry - only one friend stuck to supporting us. The others quickly shifted to "It will never last." "Are you sure she isn`t just using you?" "Dating is fine and all, but marriage is for life! Do some more thinking!" etc etc. (Guess which friend we still are in touch with these days ) We didn`t experience any family negativity, but they also weren`t jumping around because dating a foreigner was "cool". His mother got me alone in the car and asked me if I truly loved her son, and that was the end of it.

I think that you might be surprised to see the difference in reactions for "dating" and "planning to marry".


If anyone is trying to find me… Tamyuun on Instagram is probably the easiest.
Reply With Quote
(#32 (permalink))
Old
missprincess's Avatar
missprincess (Offline)
Bonnie lass from England
 
Posts: 122
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: England
12-13-2010, 03:47 AM

hmm cool topic,
i dont know alot about what japanese men think about western women in general but all i can say is i have seen some african american and east asian relationships (my friend was actually with an african american man for quite some time) and they had a baby together so it does happen
and btw interacial couples have the hottest kids! (i can vouch for that since every single guy ive pretty much ever like has been mixed race)


Don't make someone a priority....... if your nothing more than an option to them

How can the world end at 2012 when my yogurt expires in 2013?
Reply With Quote
(#33 (permalink))
Old
RealJames's Avatar
RealJames (Offline)
ボケ外人
 
Posts: 1,129
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: 神戸 三宮
12-13-2010, 04:38 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by MMM View Post
RealJames, something about your gf's grandparents sits funny with me. Saying it's "cool" she is dating a foreigner and wanting to constantly take pictures with you seems like back-handed progressivism to me.

If I were dating an African-American woman and my grandparents talked about how "cool" that was and had her pose for pictures with them, I would be VERY embarrassed and uncomfortable.

I had quite a few friends when I lived in Japan, and am still friends with a handful of them. The reason we became fairly good friends is because they didn't care that I was a foreigner. They liked me for me, not for my race or country of origin.

I, as I am sure you have, met plenty of people that wanted to be friends with me for no other reason than I am American. As I weeded out the riff-raff I was dragged to plenty of bars and introduced to plenty of people I had nothing in common with and little to talk about with. I was the "trophy friend" and it was not that fun or interesting.
Yeah her grandparents are incredibly racist, it's a twisted way to approve of me, but it does show the changing times, that her grandparents friends would think highly of her family for having an international relationship in it.

I have also heard of foreigners being invited to weddings where they were so out of place just so there was an international presence there, to glorify the ordeal.

And yes I have met loads of people that have wanted to be friends simple because I'm white, to be seen in public with me, because I can speak English, because I have blue eyes, because I can get them girls, etc etc, it sucks finding out who your true friends are when it comes down to it. But, I do think this is a representation of how Japan is embracing internationalism, wanting to have a friend because he's a foreigner, as opposed to shunning him, that's a symbol in itself, isn't it?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nyororin View Post
I think that the issue of dating a foreigner is being confused with actually marrying one.

In terms of family reaction, there is a huge difference. Most people will react with interest, fascination, approval, or even admiration when it comes to having a dating relationship with a foreigner. Move on to talk of marriage and the tables turn VERY quickly.
[...]
I think that you might be surprised to see the difference in reactions for "dating" and "planning to marry".
I think you're right, possibly because of communication problems splitting the family. I don't think the motives for it are based in racism, just practicality... don't you think so?


Quote:
Originally Posted by missprincess View Post
hmm cool topic,
and btw interacial couples have the hottest kids! (i can vouch for that since every single guy ive pretty much ever like has been mixed race)
you're SO right!!! my god mix raced chicks are soooo hot!! (*googles mixed race chicks*)


マンツーマン 英会話 神戸 三宮 リアライズ -James- This is my life and why I know things about Japan.

Last edited by RealJames : 12-13-2010 at 04:39 AM. Reason: to add missprincess quote
Reply With Quote
(#34 (permalink))
Old
MMM's Avatar
MMM (Offline)
JF Ossan
 
Posts: 12,200
Join Date: Jun 2007
12-13-2010, 04:49 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by RealJames View Post
Yeah her grandparents are incredibly racist, it's a twisted way to approve of me, but it does show the changing times, that her grandparents friends would think highly of her family for having an international relationship in it.

I have also heard of foreigners being invited to weddings where they were so out of place just so there was an international presence there, to glorify the ordeal.

And yes I have met loads of people that have wanted to be friends simple because I'm white, to be seen in public with me, because I can speak English, because I have blue eyes, because I can get them girls, etc etc, it sucks finding out who your true friends are when it comes down to it. But, I do think this is a representation of how Japan is embracing internationalism, wanting to have a friend because he's a foreigner, as opposed to shunning him, that's a symbol in itself, isn't it?
YIKES! I am glad I dug deeper. Does her grandparents racism sound like progress to you?

You have met loads of people who are interested in you because of your race and the color of your eyes. Tell me, when were white people shunned in Japan after the Meiji Restoration? Again, does this sound like progress to you?
Reply With Quote
(#35 (permalink))
Old
RealJames's Avatar
RealJames (Offline)
ボケ外人
 
Posts: 1,129
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: 神戸 三宮
12-13-2010, 05:01 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by MMM View Post
YIKES! I am glad I dug deeper. Does her grandparents racism sound like progress to you?

You have met loads of people who are interested in you because of your race and the color of your eyes. Tell me, when were white people shunned in Japan after the Meiji Restoration? Again, does this sound like progress to you?
hmm, racism generally comes with a notion of negative prejudice...
Japan is racist in a different way, positive prejudice, in my opinion...

I guess I'd rather be falsely admired than thought of as a lesser being, is what I was getting at.

excluding ww2, I'm not sure that there was any point where Japanese people hated or shunned white people.

I think my point at first was that an international/intercultural relationship would do just fine here, in fact it might do better, perhaps due to this.

I guess a black woman coming to Japan might have difficulty finding a man who likes her instead of liking her skin or what she represents in the country. Tough one to test.


マンツーマン 英会話 神戸 三宮 リアライズ -James- This is my life and why I know things about Japan.
Reply With Quote
(#36 (permalink))
Old
Ryzorian (Offline)
Busier Than Shinjuku Station
 
Posts: 1,126
Join Date: Jun 2009
12-13-2010, 05:07 AM

I think personality can help in many situations, even racial ones. However, racial undertones tend to interweave into a person's personality when they grow up. So it will depend a bit on your upbringing and the upbringing of the Japanese folks you happen to interact with.


Leastway's that's my thought on the subject.
Reply With Quote
(#37 (permalink))
Old
RealJames's Avatar
RealJames (Offline)
ボケ外人
 
Posts: 1,129
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: 神戸 三宮
12-13-2010, 05:11 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryzorian View Post
I think personality can help in many situations, even racial ones. However, racial undertones tend to interweave into a person's personality when they grow up. So it will depend a bit on your upbringing and the upbringing of the Japanese folks you happen to interact with.


Leastway's that's my thought on the subject.
I agree, and I'd add that these days more and more Japanese people are brought up to be accepting and interested in international topics/people.


マンツーマン 英会話 神戸 三宮 リアライズ -James- This is my life and why I know things about Japan.
Reply With Quote
(#38 (permalink))
Old
MMM's Avatar
MMM (Offline)
JF Ossan
 
Posts: 12,200
Join Date: Jun 2007
12-13-2010, 05:19 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by RealJames View Post
hmm, racism generally comes with a notion of negative prejudice...
Japan is racist in a different way, positive prejudice, in my opinion...

I guess I'd rather be falsely admired than thought of as a lesser being, is what I was getting at.

excluding ww2, I'm not sure that there was any point where Japanese people hated or shunned white people.

I think my point at first was that an international/intercultural relationship would do just fine here, in fact it might do better, perhaps due to this.

I guess a black woman coming to Japan might have difficulty finding a man who likes her instead of liking her skin or what she represents in the country. Tough one to test.
Even reverse racism, aka positive discrimination, is, in the end, a negative. Examples of this are that Asians excel at math, or that black people are good at sports. Well, what if you are Asian and are not good at math, or you are black and aren't good at sports. Now you are not meeting an expectation that was placed on you simply because of your race.

You know as well as I do that a relationship based on a racial presumption is doomed to failure. That's why I no longer talk to any of those "friends" back in Japan. It wasn't about me, the person, but me the white American, and not only was the relationship shallow, I was also easily replaceable.
Reply With Quote
(#39 (permalink))
Old
RealJames's Avatar
RealJames (Offline)
ボケ外人
 
Posts: 1,129
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: 神戸 三宮
12-13-2010, 05:29 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by MMM View Post
Even reverse racism, aka positive discrimination, is, in the end, a negative. Examples of this are that Asians excel at math, or that black people are good at sports. Well, what if you are Asian and are not good at math, or you are black and aren't good at sports. Now you are not meeting an expectation that was placed on you simply because of your race.

You know as well as I do that a relationship based on a racial presumption is doomed to failure. That's why I no longer talk to any of those "friends" back in Japan. It wasn't about me, the person, but me the white American, and not only was the relationship shallow, I was also easily replaceable.
This is true, we are in complete agreement.

As far as an intercultural relationship is concerned though, those people who approve or disapprove of it don't need to do so for the right reasons.
What I mean is that if a black woman marries a japanese guy and all his family and friends are cool with it, the reasons are not such a big deal, so long as the marriage isn't under strain or pressure from those who can affect it.
If, on the other hand, it were negative discrimination, it would be a huge issue.
See where I'm headed with that?


マンツーマン 英会話 神戸 三宮 リアライズ -James- This is my life and why I know things about Japan.
Reply With Quote
(#40 (permalink))
Old
inuzuki8605's Avatar
inuzuki8605 (Offline)
JF Regular
 
Posts: 30
Join Date: Dec 2010
Send a message via AIM to inuzuki8605 Send a message via Skype™ to inuzuki8605
12-13-2010, 06:02 AM

In my experience, Japanese people view African Americans as they do other Americans. (They don't really know enough about them, other than the BS that's on T.V., Movies, and Music, to make a judgment call on who or what a black person can offer.) When I went to Japan 2009-2010, I went with three other white Americans. The Japanese never called me Black, they called me American. They didn't assume I came from Africa because I was black, they didn't treat me any differently than they treated the white Americans I came with.

Thinking more and more about this... I don't think that there was a time in history when the Japanese had a problem with Africans or African Americans specifically. The problems in that regard started in the Western world and I believe that some people still try to push the beliefs that they grew up with or where exposed to on the Japanese and their way of thinking as if they, too, think like the western world. Like RealJames was talking about his gf's grandparents. They aren't racist because he is white, they are racist because he is foreign. If it were someone like my brother, a black man, they would be the same way, not because he's black but because he's foreign.

I think that it would be just as tough for a white woman, with blue eyes and blonde hair, to find a man that loves her for her and not her eyes or skin don't you think, RealJames? I know full well that a black woman would definitely stand out in Japan, but a white women would too in a place of mostly Asians.

MMM, I asked you when you lived in Japan because it's very easy to judge the reactions of a society based off of the time period you experienced..... It was quite some time ago that you experience day to day life in Japan and times have definitely changed since you lived there.

There were A LOT of people that wanted to take my picture or touch my hair (I have dreads) or even touch my boobs!!!!! (Japanese girls.... I guess to make sure they were real haha) But I never thought that they were my friends just because I was foreign. They didn't do that with my black friends from Kenya or France. I really believe it was my personally, my interests, my willingness to be outgoing (even when my Japanese wasn't good yet) that won them over.

Nyororin makes a VALID point. Dating is TOTALLY different than marriage. That's went you put up or shut up, to put it bluntly. I have no doubt about being able to date a Japanese guy because it is just dating and if I'm there long enough, it'll happen at some point. But when all cards are laid out on the table and all bets are off, it is the marriage that matters. (To me at least)

Please keep the comments coming.


A New Face
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On




Copyright 2003-2006 Virtual Japan.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6