JapanForum.com

JapanForum.com (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/)
-   General Discussion (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/general-discussion/)
-   -   I'm 外人. Tips for teaching 日本語 to soon-to-be-born nephew? (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/general-discussion/32321-im-%E5%A4%96%E4%BA%BA-tips-teaching-%E6%97%A5%E6%9C%AC%E8%AA%9E-soon-born-nephew.html)

Kururugi 06-12-2010 02:12 PM

I'm 外人. Tips for teaching 日本語 to soon-to-be-born nephew?
 
Dear Japan Forum:

My brother's son is due any day now and I have permission to teach him Japanese. Neither my brother nor his wife speak Japanese (my brother loves anime, though;)), so I will be his only relative speaking to him in a language other than English.

Can you offer any tips or, possibly, advice from past experiences with similar situations?

Thanks,

Steven

p.s., greeting my nephew after delivery, should I go with はじめまして! or is there a more appropriate greeting for a newborn?

Columbine 06-12-2010 06:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kururugi (Post 815430)

p.s., greeting my nephew after delivery, should I go with はじめまして! or is there a more appropriate greeting for a newborn?

I think I've heard people say はじめまして to new-borns. Bit confused by the plan though; are you going to be living with him/seeing him daily because if neither of his parents speak Japanese, well, you can see what I'm thinking.

Basically just talk in Japanese how you'd talk to an infant in English. Slightly exaggerate the syntax. Until he actually starts talking, exposure to the sound is probably the most key thing.

MMM 06-12-2010 07:43 PM

You might say はじめまして as sort of a joke, like "It's a pleasure meeting you," to a newborn.

I am curious, what your goals are in speaking Japanese to a baby, and how many years do you plan on keeping it up?

Kururugi 06-12-2010 09:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Columbine
Bit confused by the plan though; are you going to be living with him/seeing him daily because if neither of his parents speak Japanese, well, you can see what I'm thinking.

Quote:

Originally Posted by MMM
I am curious, what your goals are in speaking Japanese to a baby, and how many years do you plan on keeping it up?

As to the plan, I expect to see him most days and I'm hoping speaking Japanese to him will help confer some of the advantages of being raised bilingually. (A sub-plan is that my brother has wanted to learn Japanese for several years but has dragged his feet, so hearing his son respond to or speak it may finally encourage him to learn it.)

I plan on sticking with it for at least the first few years.

Do either of you know if, say, NHK or the Japanese Department of Education offer courses or videos? Or maybe of a Dora the Explorer-like program that incorporates English and Japanese?

Thanks for confirming はじめまして for me. :)

Best,

Steven

Nyororin 06-13-2010 03:10 AM

It`s not a joke, and is a pretty common thing for new parents and family to say to babies. Along with よろしく and the like.

As for teaching them Japanese... Well, do you speak it fluently? Are you going to speak ONLY Japanese to them? It`s not as simple as just randomly teaching some words.

Kururugi 06-13-2010 09:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nyororin (Post 815503)
It`s not a joke, and is a pretty common thing for new parents and family to say to babies. Along with よろしく and the like.

Thank you.

Quote:

As for teaching them Japanese... Well, do you speak it fluently? Are you going to speak ONLY Japanese to them? It`s not as simple as just randomly teaching some words.
I took it for two years in college and still speak it pretty well, but I'm not fluent. I haven't ever really had any ongoing interactions with babies, but have been told that a lot of the time I'll just be doing "kore/sore/are wa [noun] desu/desu ka"-type identifying activities with the baby.

I plan to speak very little, if any, English around the baby. I will speak English to my family, of course, which will hopefully be all the English he hears me speak. I plan on putting in the extra time needed to improve both my reading and verbal fluency so he doesn't learn a hackneyed version of the language.

Apologies for the romaji. I haven't installed Anthy on this computer yet. :)

Steven

SHAD0W 06-13-2010 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kururugi (Post 815538)
I took it for two years in college

Hurrhurrhurr, just thought about some of my 2nd Year Japanese classmates and how their language skills are. Wouldn't want them teaching me Japanese!

"Hageemaymashyte aka-san"

*shudder*

Kururugi 06-13-2010 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SHAD0W (Post 815558)
Hurrhurrhurr, just thought about some of my 2nd Year Japanese classmates and how their language skills are. Wouldn't want them teaching me Japanese!

"Hageemaymashyte aka-san"

Haha! Well, I can't write due to a spinal cord injury, so my verbal score was weighted heavier than others and I still maintained a 4.0. :)

Nyororin 06-14-2010 01:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kururugi (Post 815538)
I took it for two years in college and still speak it pretty well, but I'm not fluent. I haven't ever really had any ongoing interactions with babies, but have been told that a lot of the time I'll just be doing "kore/sore/are wa [noun] desu/desu ka"-type identifying activities with the baby.

This bit makes me sort of raise my eyebrows. Formal speech to a baby...?
While "baby talk" may not be necessary, simplification is. That kind of grammar doesn`t come into play for quite a while. You want to communicate with the least number of words. (~なーに? ~だね! etc ) and an emphasis on the important part you want to teach. (おおきな~だね! ながーい~だよ! etc)

I won`t say that you should give up, but I think it would be a good idea to look into actual material for children. Watch some shows aimed at babies. Just as you wouldn`t start out speaking to a baby with stiff and formal English, you don`t in Japanese.

Kururugi 06-14-2010 03:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nyororin (Post 815637)
This bit makes me sort of raise my eyebrows. Formal speech to a baby...?
While "baby talk" may not be necessary, simplification is. That kind of grammar doesn`t come into play for quite a while. You want to communicate with the least number of words. (~なーに? ~だね! etc ) and an emphasis on the important part you want to teach. (おおきな~だね! ながーい~だよ! etc)

Thanks! This is why I came here for information. :)

Quote:

I won`t say that you should give up, but I think it would be a good idea to look into actual material for children. Watch some shows aimed at babies. Just as you wouldn`t start out speaking to a baby with stiff and formal English, you don`t in Japanese.
Do you know of any that would be good? I asked in post #4 but got no response.

spoonybard 06-14-2010 11:02 PM

I don't know much about the baby part, but I found this a long time ago(however, it is formal stuff, check out the "Learn" section). Kids Web Japan

Also, for kanji learning, you WILL need to use this in conjunction with other kanji learning material, first of all, because this doesn't present you with all definitions for each kanji(at most, they only have one or two definitions), and second of all, because it only has up to the sixth grade. Here is the site: https://www.msu.edu/~lakejess/kanjigame.html

I recommend Tuttle's A Guide to Reading and Writing Japanese, because it includes all the definitions, on-yomi and kun-yomi readings, a few compounds, plus the stroke order and all kanji needed for complete literacy(the only kanji they don't go into are the kanji that the Japan Newspaper Association added for use in newspapers). I love this book. Finally, maybe LiveMocha can help a wee bit Language Learning with Livemocha | Learn a Language Online - Free!. I hope some of this helps.

kirakira 06-15-2010 02:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kururugi (Post 815430)
Dear Japan Forum:

Can you offer any tips or, possibly, advice from past experiences with similar situations?

Either hire a nanny who is Japanese native and instruct him/her to only speak Japanese full time to the baby or don't do it. Babies don't learn languages like adults, they just do the monkey-see-monkey-do thing which makes them learn much much quicker but only if the carer is 100% fluent.

2 years of Japanese tuition is not enough for fluency. Any mistakes you make (and you will make lots), the baby will pick it up and commit to memory and it would be very hard to correct later.

Kururugi 06-15-2010 02:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kirakira (Post 815827)
2 years of Japanese tuition is not enough for fluency. Any mistakes you make (and you will make lots), the baby will pick it up and commit to memory and it would be very hard to correct later.

That seems to be the popular opinion, so let me try to reframe the questions.

Would watching Japanese children's programming, like PythagoraSwitch, be beneficial to my nephew?

Which level JLPT would I need to complete to be considered competent to speak Japanese to a baby?

Steven

spoonybard 06-15-2010 09:56 PM

If you're doing it according to the JLPT, you will most likely only be able to speak formal Japanese, which is fine, because of the politeness, however, according to a fairly large amount of people, if you are really familiar with a Japanese person, they get offended if you use polite Japanese. In other words, there are two types of Japanese; formal, which is more likely than not the one that will be used more often, therefore is taught most, and informal Japanese, which is used amongst close friends and unfortunately in most anime, which means that watching anime for the purpose of learning Japanese is really not the way to go, although I would imagine that the stuff made to educate kids would be different.

I agree with kirakira; hire someone that can speak fluent Japanese to take care of the kid, and you may also learn a fair amount of things as well. Also, you should probably go to a university that teaches the language so that you can learn it to where you can pass the JLPT 1 test, but remember that they call it "almost native level", because of the two different types of Japanese, and the informal stuff can only really be learned through speaking with the people from whence the language came. If you do take a university coarse, the teacher may also be of help regarding teaching the language to a baby.

Nyororin 06-16-2010 01:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kururugi (Post 815909)
Would watching Japanese children's programming, like PythagoraSwitch, be beneficial to my nephew?

Without any exposure in daily life? Not very. Plus, we`re talking about a baby. They should not be watching tv AT ALL until 2 or 3, and even then just barely. Don`t believe any of the educational tv hype - it`s never been proven to do anything other than slow development.
Once they are that age, then they might be able to pick up a word or two from things like Inai Inai Baa (Pythagora Switch is aimed at older kids)... But the thing is, without starting knowledge the talking on tv is just going to be background noise. To put it into perspective, try watching some shows in a language you know nothing of (have never studied, know 0 words in) - and see how hard it is to pick up things without confirmation and interaction.

Another good example would be that there are hours of English children`s programming on tv each day in Japan... Undoubtedly with countless children watching it to "pick up" English. Instead, they pick up a handful of words that aren`t pronounced correctly... And that`s if they`re lucky and are good at picking things up like that.

Quote:

Which level JLPT would I need to complete to be considered competent to speak Japanese to a baby?
When you no longer think in terms of JLPT would be my answer.
The JLPT isn`t what matters when it comes to teaching the language to someone from scratch. You can be a horrible speaker, not be able to scrape a decent sentence together, have an appalling accent that native speakers cannot understand at ALL... And still pass the JLPT - possibly all the way up to 1. It measures a very thin slice of knowledge, and hopes that you have the rest. Unless things have changed since I took it, they don`t do a simple test of speaking even for JLPT1.

RickOShay 06-16-2010 04:14 AM

Not to be a downer, but without being fluent and speaking to the baby and probably with someone else around the baby, you will probably not accomplish much more than Seasame Street did with me and Spanish... 1-10 and water.

If you can, hire a nanny, or send the child to a Japanese language school for kids. But really, if the kid has no Japanese blood, or real reason to learn Japanese, why put them through something like that? I mean if the child enjoys it, it is ok I suppose, but I would not force anything like that on them.

robhol 06-16-2010 04:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SHAD0W (Post 815558)
Hurrhurrhurr, just thought about some of my 2nd Year Japanese classmates and how their language skills are. Wouldn't want them teaching me Japanese!

"Hageemaymashyte aka-san"

*shudder*

Hahaha. I wonder how people would do here in Norway.. Oddly, the languages are pronounced very similarly.. (Not to say the languages are similar by themselves, obviously, but the "sounds" being used are.) :)


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:39 PM.

Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6