JapanForum.com

JapanForum.com (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/)
-   Japanese Food (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/japanese-food/)
-   -   Why Chopsticks? (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/japanese-food/10035-why-chopsticks.html)

Hyakushi 12-01-2007 04:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vulgarshudder (Post 313839)
Was Tenchu always such a troll?

Is troll some kind of secret code for something? like . . . nevermind . . .

MMM 12-01-2007 08:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ITADAKIMASU (Post 314585)
look it up in urbandictionary

A troll is someone that answers in ways to incite anger from other posters or create conflict where is doesn't exist.

Tenchu creates conflict, but not because he's a troll, but because he is loopy.

noodle 12-01-2007 10:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 314638)
Agreed, cept I do not use the word 'loopy' :mad: , I prefer 'the mentally and emotionally challenged' :) .

LOL, no really, I am often harsh, but it is always inspired by something said. Someone who is mean for no reason is a troll. Sides, a lot of the time people think I am being mean, I am just being brutally honest on what I think, and it is not directed at anyone. Everyone who thinks I am mean to them should step back first and consider if I am really talking to them or about them or not. Coz a lot of people mis understand me. I am not looking for an argument here on this forum. The talks I like best are in depth ones where we do disagree (coz if you both agree on everything it ends quick) but still are nice to each other. Someone who gets emotionally involved on a computer is a bit fruity...

i've never had a problem with you and i don't think you're too mean... in fact you might argue agresively but that doesn't make you mean... just like me, if you say something against what i truely believe in, i'll kick your ass verbally, but that doesn't make me mean!!!

;) ignore the people that think you're mean, those people always want someone to agree with them instead of argue, i can actually name a few people like that on this site that bug the hell out of me cos they say the stupidest shit just so they fit in with everyone else

temudzjin 12-01-2007 10:17 AM

Though i'm dutch personally chopsticks are just more fun to eat with.
And for the western eating method? well all you really need is an spoon.
Ahh the things you learn in the asylum (Army) really amazing :)

MMM 12-01-2007 10:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by noodle (Post 314644)
i've never had a problem with you and i don't think you're too mean... in fact you might argue agresively but that doesn't make you mean... just like me, if you say something against what i truely believe in, i'll kick your ass verbally, but that doesn't make me mean!!!

;) ignore the people that think you're mean, those people always want someone to agree with them instead of argue, i can actually name a few people like that on this site that bug the hell out of me cos they say the stupidest shit just so they fit in with everyone else

I have plenty of problems with some of Tenchu's opinions...but not in his ability to post.

You know I'll fight tooth-and-nail about my opinions, too.

I bet we both have the same short list of ...undesireables...

noodle 12-01-2007 10:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MMM (Post 314655)
I have plenty of problems with some of Tenchu's opinions...but not in his ability to post.

You know I'll fight tooth-and-nail about my opinions, too.

I bet we both have the same short list of ...undesireables...

Yep, i know... thats probably one of the reasons i like to debate with you!! To be honest, the only 3 people i like to even debate with or consider their posts "seriously" enough for me to react are You, Tenchu and ivi0nk3y.
The simple reason for this is none of you seem to follow the crowd without thinking, though sometimes i will disagree with your reasonings, at least you didn't just accept what a newsreporter or teacher said to you!!!

loveless09 12-03-2007 01:46 AM

only thing im having trouble with is trying to pick up the tofu they put in miso soup. i love me some miso soup but that tofu is just so slippery since its waterlogged. But miso soaked tofu is the best tasting tofu ever...except for jerked tofu and fried tofu...MMMmmmmm^^

i miss having miso and tofu with breakfast and dinner everyday...(T-T)

dont get me started on tuna and mayo onigiri...HEAVEN

Camui 12-04-2007 12:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by noodle (Post 314661)
Yep, i know... thats probably one of the reasons i like to debate with you!! To be honest, the only 3 people i like to even debate with or consider their posts "seriously" enough for me to react are You, Tenchu and ivi0nk3y.
The simple reason for this is none of you seem to follow the crowd without thinking, though sometimes i will disagree with your reasonings, at least you didn't just accept what a newsreporter or teacher said to you!!!

I like you already. xD

Anyone on a forum who states their mind without letting other's bias get in the way has a good head on their shoulders. Too many people nowadays go with the flow, jump on the bandwagon, etc.

As for me, I state my mind, and if someone doesn't like what I say, I don't get mad at them, I respect them. That's not to say that I don't take up for myself as well though. ;)

Anyway, chopsticks are really fun and intriguing to eat with, in my opinion. Ever since I first started eating with them (for any type of food in America that is suited for chopsticks xD) I have been using them ever since. Especially with ramen. xD

Now, I do see how chopsticks could improve your concentration. To a certain extent, at least while you are learning how to use them, I'd say that it is possible. One reason being that you have to concentrate so that your fingers support the chopsticks, while also gripping onto the food. xD

In history, at least from what I have read, when the Europeans first explored Japan, they brought with them their knives. In early European times, they didn't use forks and spoons yet. So, to a Japanese person, the way a European person ate, looked rather untidy and disgusting to them. xD The Europeans only ate with a knife and their hands.

Chopsticks look much more graceful to me. I personally like eating with chopsticks over a knife, spoon, and fork, but that could also have to with my love of Japan. xD

Anyway, back on history...the Japanese didn't want to use a knife, because they thought that a sharp object should not be present at the dinner table. Or rather, an object that was like a sword, probably to them.

I admire how the Japanese have kept their heritage of eating with chopsticks.

Now, that is just a rough history about the chopstick. If anyone knows more about it, feel free to post more about it.

Also, sorry if I posted anything that someone else has stated already. I didn't look back at the other pages. xD

Ebba 12-07-2007 10:06 PM

so much easier to find two sticks than a fork in the woods :p
it's probably a matter of history. Asian people were civilized compared to westarn people that mostly ate with their hands :D

ChisaChi 12-11-2007 02:03 AM

Hey now, eating with hands is not uncivilized! In plenty of countries it's the traditional way of eating, and is supposed to make the food taste better :) Different methods of eating for different foods, makes sense.

DivineBled 12-22-2007 05:50 AM

Personally, picking up food with chopsticks is much easier than with a spoon, a fork or in some cases, its offspring........the spork.

Uriko 12-22-2007 06:28 AM

because i just love the chopsticks like i love rice.

antoniopratas 01-13-2008 07:15 PM

what about being healthier? with chopsticks you don't put so much on your mouth at once like if using fork and knife.. so you take longer to eat, you feel full quicker and you eat less than you'd probably eat in western style. but even if you eat just as much, you don't eat so much at a time, so it's better for you.

Kiyuge 01-13-2008 07:52 PM

Because chopsicks are awsome DUH! ^^

Katia 01-18-2008 03:52 AM

I find chopsticks is a lot easier to use then a fork, its much easier~~

ciao

odonata 02-15-2008 03:11 AM

Forks, (eating) knives and spoons have not been around forever in europe!
The French have alot to answer for in using specialised eating tools for various dishes.

I would think that Japan with its limited earth resources like metals and minerals would focus the resources it had on farming impliments and weapons and not on eating tools that could be achieved using wood.

Chopsticks are just an exstension of forefinger and thumb and are a perfect way of getting food to your mouth without using your fingers which as many ancient civilisations have found spreads illness and disease.

It would also indicate that the user has adiquate co-ordination and is not a clumsy fool. this is of great importance when weighing up your fellow diners prospects.

Amnell 02-15-2008 04:21 AM

I love using hashi~! I only recently figured out how to do it, too XP . Only problem is that they make my hand hurt sometimes, which probably means I'm doing something a little wrong :P .

I wouldn't say that using chopsticks is easier than using a fork or vice versa. They're both pretty easy, really. I'd say that forks (and knives) are more suited to European food, Hashi to Asian food, and both are pretty adaptable to other cuisine types--Mexican, for example, usually has its meat cut into bite size pieces like Japanese. Of course, Mexican and a lot of American are "finger" food, so :P .

Let me tell ya, though: Chopsticks and fettuccine alfredo don't work well together unless the sticks have barbs on the end O_O . On the other hand, eating Chow Mein or Soba with a fork is exceedingly dull.

petrifiedexuberance 02-15-2008 08:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DivineBled (Post 333762)
Personally, picking up food with chopsticks is much easier than with a spoon, a fork or in some cases, its offspring........the spork.

Agreed, I can use chopsticks for anything except the huge chunks of meat people like to eat here, and I find them much easier to use than wester silver.

Sinner 02-15-2008 11:18 AM

I think it's just a tradition, someone started it and then in some way people thinked it was practical. That's what I think.

T92 02-15-2008 05:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fara7 (Post 310682)
I am not trying to make fun or anything but why do Japanese, Koreans and others use chopsticks? isn't it much easier to just take a spoon or fork and eat their food? I know this may sound a bit stupid :p but i am just curious why.

I just heard before that eating using chopsticks improves your concentration power, is that true? and are there any other benefits of using chopsticks?


They do use spoons for some foods.
Some places in eastern asia it's concidered uncivilised to eat with a fork because they think of it as if it was weapon.

Although i am used to eat with knife fork and spoon, I don't consider it difficult to use chopsticks. And i think the "chopstick food" taste better when eating with chopsticks. wood taste better than metal?

As long as you know how to place them in your hand it should be easy. I think using chopsticks is easy with a little practice.

It would be difficult to a person who never have eaten with fork or spoon to suddenly eat with that too.

And if it is more difficult to eat with chopsticks, eating with chopsticks would improve you consentration because doing something difficult force you to consentrate!
:ywave:

Slykaz1 02-15-2008 05:33 PM

OMG! It feels weird to go from chopsticks to fork.......I've been eating with chopsticks for the past two months and I tried a fork......OMG I felt awkward eating with a fork.

kireikoori 02-15-2008 06:06 PM

Personally, I find eating several foods easier with chopsticks. For ramen and rice chopsticks a must, I would struggle to eat those things with a fork or spoon.

Tturtle 02-15-2008 06:11 PM

you have to use chop sticks because you look stupid eating sushi with a fork

drummachick 02-15-2008 06:12 PM

A lot of food is easier to eat that way. Sushi with a fork? Naaaaahhh. Once you get used to it you may actually start to prefer them over other utensils. I do at least.

hypekstatic 02-16-2008 05:33 AM

Wait... who said we don't use spoons??
How would we eat soup? lolll
Well I'm pretty sure that before asians even realized
what a fork was, they thought of chopsticks. It's like the most
simplistic of eating utensils, but of course it's much harder to use them
than forks because a fork is a more complicated made utensil which leads to
a easier use of it. Well thats my theory anyway... as for confucious and all
that, i don't know. I just know that Chinese used it first then korea and japan.

I can't use chopsticks correctly xP so when I go eat with my grandparents
who are traditional, they smack me in the head T_T but trying to use it
the right way is really hard for me cuz im used to the way i hold them.
either way, i eat with chopsticks most of the time, the only time i dont is
at american restaurants. when i get lazy though i just use one stick and
poke the food xD HA (ps, koreans use metal chopsticks [well i dont lol] and it is freaking hard!)

VisualKei 02-16-2008 01:20 PM

Um... for the same reason we use forks and spoons. That's the way they were raised, it's the way their parents ate and taught them to eat. I'm sure sometimes they wonder why we eat with forks and spoons :P

HYDfan 02-20-2008 03:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nyororin (Post 310719)
Why do other places use spoons and forks? Isn`t it a lot easier to actually have some control over the thing you`re eating than to just stab it or try to scoop it up?

I like your point. It just goes to show that we all have a different view. Once I started learning the correct way to use chopsticks, I realized that they weren't that hard and actually really suited for rice and asian food.

iamjenii 02-20-2008 04:54 PM

For a lot of people and where they grow up, it's also by preference. Most Asians grow up on chop sticks. It's not like we don't use other utensils, it really also depends on the food. And since most Asian cultures use chop sticks as a main utensil, much food is also centered around its usability.

I get lazy sometimes but most of the time, I'll use chop sticks for almost everything I eat.

NonStopReaper 02-21-2008 10:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iamjenii (Post 405133)
For a lot of people and where they grow up, it's also by preference. Most Asians grow up on chop sticks. It's not like we don't use other utensils, it really also depends on the food. And since most Asian cultures use chop sticks as a main utensil, much food is also centered around its usability.

I get lazy sometimes but most of the time, I'll use chop sticks for almost everything I eat.

lol i grew up using spoons and forks and chopsticks. while my parent just use chopsticks. i only use chop sticks soo i can reach across the table to get whatever foods over there. I use the spoon to eat my rice... i know i'm too americanized -_- i always have a spoon,fork and chopstick. but when i eat out an certain places i use chopsticks

tifa 02-21-2008 10:56 PM

noodle.... my hero.. and scary person...* sneaks off be4 noodle glares at me with the look off "are u stupid"*

xYinniex 02-21-2008 11:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hypekstatic (Post 400495)
Wait... who said we don't use spoons??
How would we eat soup? lolll
Well I'm pretty sure that before asians even realized
what a fork was, they thought of chopsticks. It's like the most
simplistic of eating utensils, but of course it's much harder to use them
than forks because a fork is a more complicated made utensil which leads to
a easier use of it. Well thats my theory anyway... as for confucious and all
that, i don't know. I just know that Chinese used it first then korea and japan.

I can't use chopsticks correctly xP so when I go eat with my grandparents
who are traditional, they smack me in the head T_T but trying to use it
the right way is really hard for me cuz im used to the way i hold them.
either way, i eat with chopsticks most of the time, the only time i dont is
at american restaurants. when i get lazy though i just use one stick and
poke the food xD HA (ps, koreans use metal chopsticks [well i dont lol] and it is freaking hard!)

yeah, i grew up using chopsticks too! but i also don't hold them correctly. BUT HEY, THAT WORKS FINE WITH ME.

I do use other utensils but its mainly spoons and chopsticks.

I go back to Hong Kong or Malaysia and it's really embarassing because my younger cousins can hold chopsticks better than i do.

*hangs head in shame*

SSJup81 02-24-2008 03:41 AM

It may have been said already, and if I'm repeating, I do apologize. I recall hearing or either reading someplace that the reason things like chopsticks are used, is to help with one's coordination and concentration. I guess it's like hand-eye coordination. I don't know if there's any truth to this, though.

Odin 02-24-2008 06:34 AM

The use of forks has always been slow to spread!
  • Evidence show they have been used in the mid-east since about 700 BCE.
  • They gained some acceptance in the northern Mediterranean by 1st century C.E.
  • However did not catch on in northern Europe till the early 1600's
There was a common belief that one should eat as God intended, with your fingers.

In contrast it took chopsticks less than 150 years to spread from the Uyghur people in western Mongolia to Japan during the Nara period (~ 750C.E.)

Kajitsu 02-24-2008 07:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nyororin (Post 310719)
Why do other places use spoons and forks? Isn`t it a lot easier to actually have some control over the thing you`re eating than to just stab it or try to scoop it up?

Good point, and thank you for the perspective.

artificalflavor 03-25-2008 10:12 PM

I think that it's just a matter of what you grow up doing, if you grow up eating with chopsticks, chopsticks seem better. Where as if you grow up eating with a fork, you think that forks are better

larajolyn 03-25-2008 10:22 PM

wha he said...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MMM (Post 311707)
This is a very fair question.

Chopsticks fit with Japanese culture perfectly. In Japan food is art, and food is appreciated, and food is loved. You will find people say that in Japanese cuisine presentation is just as important as flavor. It must stimulate more than one of the senses. It should please the eye, the nose, the mouth, even touch and sound are important. Sensory peace, tranquility and balance are valuble. In the west these ideas are largely ignored.

So with that in mind, think about chopsticks, and think about western utensils. Chopsticks can stir, mix, move and carry. The soft piece of tofu, bite of rice or slice of sashimi makes its path from the small plate to your mouth delicately carried by two long, pliable pieces of wood. The food remains in the same form until the moment it hits your tongue.

This is eating food properly in Japan. What better time to be harmonious with nature and with your self than at mealtime?

Do you still wonder why they don't use violent metal weapons to stab, slice, butcher, and cut up their food?

Wow... i love what he said! and he has a good point too. :D

Akira303 04-09-2008 01:52 PM

Well the Japanese originated from China. Back in the Shang Dynasty, Confiucious found it to be violent to eat with forks and knives, so, chopsticks were invented as a solution.

TalnSG 04-12-2008 08:53 AM

My apology for not coming forth sooner in praise of your poetry, MMM. I was not here. Some people see poetry in the world around them more than others. Personally I enjoyed the post.

My preference for eating utensils are in this order:
fingers
chopsticks
spoons
forks
knives

Knives and spoons are more for cooking than eating when I am not where my table manners are being judged.

I was rasied by a proper British nanny and then spent the rest of my life with my father chastising my european style of use of KFS instead of the American customs.

Sometime in my early teens I learned to use chopsticks (took about 10 minutes I think), and they have been my preference ever since though they were not always acceptable around my parents and work colleagues.

The only time I found them unmanageable was when I had surgery on my wrist. It did result in food flying across the table, but I couldn't sign my name at the time either because my thumb was non-functional.

I once got into a distasteful conflict with a waiter in one of Dallas's largest Japanese restaurants because he thought I should drink my soup from the bowl (usually my preference) but I requested a spoon. The altercation ensued because as a waiter he should never have denied me such a request.

More recently I found myself slightly insulted at a local Chinese restaurant however. It seems they give chopsticks to you if you look Asian, but not if they think you are white or Mexican. I felt like they were deciding that because I am white I don't know how to use them, but after reading this thread maybe I had it backward. Anyway problem solved - I carry my own in my purse!

Actually I have four sets of table ware (2 silver, 2 brass) and I have a collection of chopsticks that is always growing. Somewhere over 20 pair not counting the disposable ones that collect around the house from the local Chinese delivery.

MMM, my good chopsticks are works of art, used to appreciate artistic cuisine. ;)

yuujirou 04-14-2008 03:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xYinniex (Post 406661)
yeah, i grew up using chopsticks too! but i also don't hold them correctly. BUT HEY, THAT WORKS FINE WITH ME.

I do use other utensils but its mainly spoons and chopsticks.

I go back to Hong Kong or Malaysia and it's really embarassing because my younger cousins can hold chopsticks better than i do.

*hangs head in shame*

actually x.x'''
a LOT of people hold chopsticks incorrectly x.x''
if i'm correct, the correct method is to place your median finger inbetween the chopsticks...but most people like to place it on the side...next to the index >.>"
but then again...holding chopsticks is like holding a pencil x3
whichever way works~~
as long as you get the food in (and neatly) who cares?! =DD

oh and traditionally, chopsticks were actually reserved for royalty >.>'''
peasants, until...like 1500 or so (random guess), used only their fingers too eat. >.>'''
soo i guess it's relatively recent that chopsticks were commonly used by people of all classes x.x

andd like some guy said easier...most eastern foods are cut into bite sized pieces, so that there really isn't any need for a knife >.>"""
also...forks...are just bloody horrid =OOO
i mean.. seriously..stabbing the mess outta the food and then slowly eating it off a 3-4 pronged utensil??
that's just beastly x3
not much compared to the elegance and grace of gently picking up a piece of food w/o ever damaging it's meat >.>'''...atleast until you take a bite outta it :3


oh and just a note~
nigiri-zushi is traditionally eaten w/ teh fingers >.>"'
buut...i guess most people likie to use hashi now...

yuujirou 04-14-2008 04:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tenchu (Post 459744)
I don't think so. I think that as a sensationalized assumption people make. If a person has good manners, then why is it beastly?

Also, the common fork in average households looks not good. But you can get more expensive cutlery made usually of silver, and it looks really attractive, usually more longer and slender looking. An elegance in dining utensils that far out weighs the appearance of any chop stick.

haha~ i was jk about that :3
but apparently not everyone shares the same humour w/ this one about the "barbarians from the west" x33
but the common chopstick/hashi is comparitve to teh common house hold fork in that case x.x''
because hashi can be quite ornated and made of precious metals as well >.>"
anything from steel to gold and silver.

and the cylindrical shape of teh hashi doesn't really mean they can't be as exquisitely decorated or sometimes even more so than western culterly sets >.>'
loool~


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:09 PM.

Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6