Quote:
Originally Posted by BobbyCooper
But Suki^^ it's still a remake 
I just don't think that a remake should make it into the top 10 list. |
Why not? There's more to a film than who was first to come up with the screenplay. You can give the very same script to two different directors for them to make a movie and one can turn out to be a masterpiece while the other makes the whole story look lame and unworthy of having been made into a film. Maybe it has all the more merit that Scorsese took someone else's script and made it into a great movie, even better than the one that had been made first.
Quote:
Originally Posted by BobbyCooper
To the others, I don't think a movie should be in the top 10 just because it has had such a huge impact on cinema. Then Odysee 2001 must be in everybodys top 10 as well.
|
It is often found on Top 10 lists. No wonder why.