JapanForum.com

JapanForum.com (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/)
-   Japanese Fashion (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/japanese-fashion/)
-   -   Do you think overweight girls or thinner girls... (https://www.japanforum.com/forum/japanese-fashion/30485-do-you-think-overweight-girls-thinner-girls.html)

MikeB 07-21-2010 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WingsToDiscovery (Post 820851)
Not to seem harsh, but your first paragraph really is BS. It's unfortunate that most people do not understand that not everyone is built the same way, but your justification is almost hilarious, and if I were a large person, I would probably feel insulted if my counter-defense for being big is that I can survive bad weather, just like whales.

That may be taken as offensive indeed, but that doesn't alter the truth of the argument, one way or the other. We human beings are animals and whether you like it or not, we are genetically identical to our homosapien Stone Age ancestors. Despite living in technologically advanced societies complete with various supermarkets, trains, cars, elavators and lifts we have not physically changed from being hunter-gatherers who had to endure shortages of food. Consequently, we are naturally inclined look for fat, sugar, starch and salt, because, prehistorically speaking, these things were very hard to find. So, when we see them in great amounts, our bodies find it tough to say "no".

Fat collects in two forms -

White adipose tissue - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Stored for energy and insulation.

Combine that with people living in colder climates, whereby heat is also a scarce commodity, then fat is very valuable indeed; especially brown fat which can be burned by the body to produce heat.

Brown adipose tissue - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is increasingly well understood by the scientific community.

The differences between how we have evolved, and the amount of food we have access to now is at the very heart of the issue. Evolutionarily speaking, we aren't different to our Neolithic ancestors, who didn't have access to McDonalds and if they did, they'd be fucking huge.

This is a good book to get started -

Amazon.com: Waistland: The R/evolutionary Science Behind Our Weight and Fitness Crisis (9780393062168): Deirdre Barrett: Books

Quote:

Originally Posted by WingsToDiscovery (Post 820851)
The "too skinny" argument is also pretty crappy. Being too skinny can cause health complications, but we're talking almost malnourished people, on average. Whereas someone can be as low as 15-25 lbs overweight and already begin to enter dangerous territory.
I like to use the "Money doesn't buy you happiness" analogy. I happen to disagree with that statement. The reason being, for every one filthy rich person you can find that's unhappy, I can find 1,000 impoverished people who are just as unhappy. Just as you can find one person who is skinny to the point of health complications, and I can find you 1,000 people who are pre-diabetics or worse. It's all relative.

Not sure about the money happiness thing, I'm afraid you lost me there... Being too skinny does cause serious health complications if you're anorexic or bolemic, something which the fashion industry does seem to some extent encourage. This is similarly well understood -

Fashion industry 'fuelling the rise in eating disorders' - Telegraph

Eating Disorders Somehow Still Occuring In Fashion Industry

Quote:

Originally Posted by WingsToDiscovery (Post 820851)
As for changing the market to fit bigger people, would this be a positive or a negative? All things equal, most large people are fat, not just "big boned." So would we be encouraging the idea that it is OK to be fat, and that you'll be rewarded with alternative clothing styles no matter how much weight you want to put on? All while isolating the "small" crowd and simple reversing the roles?

Fat isn't always unhealthy -

Obese people not always unhealthy - Telegraph

That's not the whole point, it's an economic issue as much as anything else, though skinny people can be just as unhealthy -

Fat risk even if you are healthy weight - Telegraph

My point was this, to be a successful company you need to sell products, if you want to sell lots of products then why restrict your product range to within a certain size when large proportions of the population exist outside of that size.

Quote:

Originally Posted by WingsToDiscovery (Post 820851)
It's unfortunate that your sister was bullied though, especially if she wasn't even that big to begin with. People's perception of what qualifies as being big is starting to become skewed.

Cheers mate, but that's the reality girls have to live with today...

Emilia 07-22-2010 03:27 PM

In my own opinion, I think that bigger girls look cuter in it than the skinnies. If you think about it, Lolita is pretty much based off of old Victorian and 19th century dress. In those days, it was the fat ones who were considered attractive. This opinion might also be a little biased. (life-long civil war reenactor) I've seen a lot of bigger people wearin the vintage style in my day. Haha. But I think that both skinny people and bigger people can pull it off.

Who has the right to say that you can't wear something because of your size? It's expression. Why deny somebody that right just because they "don't fit the standard?" Beauty isn't only on the exterior, but the interior as well. Someone can be skinny and beautiful, but still be hideous on the inside. It all comes back to judging. Don't judge. Didn't we learn that as children?

crossline 07-27-2010 02:31 PM

regarding size and shape. i'm sure there are a few ways to alter and redesign clothes. the "fat" girls clothes may not look great with the "skinny" one and vice versa. Virtual Fashion Works here's where i got my designing toy. it's totally fun.

colovegirl 08-13-2010 08:27 AM

I am really indignant. Why a fat girl can't wear a lolita dress? I am fat girl and still wear my lolita dress. I think my sweet lolita dress help accentuate my cuteness.:mad:

EpicPhysicist 08-13-2010 03:02 PM

rawr
 
I think some fat girls can pull it off. But not very overweight. ON A SIDENOTE:
I always throw up my food when seeing fat girls with booty shorts( NO OFFENSE) But dude its ******* gross. like the legfat and assfat jus jiggling to no extent. its like COVER IT UP>!!!!

StephanieJune 08-14-2010 07:35 PM

I think it depends a lot on the person, their atittude, and fashion sense. Ive seen some skinny chicks that couldnt pull off loli because it just didnt suit them whereas someone overweight totally rocked the look.

Qayin 08-15-2010 11:12 AM

It's their body everything is up to them. I admit that sometimes I see people wear or have hairstyle that's very mismatch to them, but do I have the right to stop them? NO! because it's their right so eventhough I don't like them, I got to respect them. That's the rule of the society. You don't need to agree, but you got to respect!

NanteNa 08-20-2010 01:30 PM

I think slender girls pull it off better. The Lolita style though has never really appealed to my taste. It reminds me of little girls, and I'm not really into that loli pornish stuff. >_<"
I think girls, that are overweight, should stop trying to squeeze themselves into something that doesn't fit. Not all clothes will fit EVERYONE - and that's a fact.

Tsuzuki 08-20-2010 07:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NanteNa (Post 825171)
I think slender girls pull it off better. The Lolita style though has never really appealed to my taste. It reminds me of little girls, and I'm not really into that loli pornish stuff. >_<"
I think girls, that are overweight, should stop trying to squeeze themselves into something that doesn't fit. Not all clothes will fit EVERYONE - and that's a fact.

"trying to squeeze themselves into something that doesn't fit" .... lol sweety never go to Walmart then ~.~ scary stuff runs around there x3
like XXXXXXXXXL people try to wear L or M clothes >< I mean it looks horrible but the other thing is it must hurts alot ><

NanteNa 08-21-2010 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLastFortnight (Post 825334)
Girls can be mean sometimes...

Haha, you'd be surprised how many girls actually dress up to impress one another spite to impress their boyfriends or guys in general ; D You can say that we keep each other fit. Haha!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tsuzuki (Post 825204)
"trying to squeeze themselves into something that doesn't fit" .... lol sweety never go to Walmart then ~.~ scary stuff runs around there x3
like XXXXXXXXXL people try to wear L or M clothes >< I mean it looks horrible but the other thing is it must hurts alot ><

I actually have a tshirt from walmart form the boys' department (no one saw that..). WITH SPIDERMAN! YEAHH! In general many Americans are obese - but they are a lot of people in a big country. So it makes sense.

Nikeshoxsale 08-24-2010 01:43 AM

Personality charm designer
 
Increase product quality brand image is the best advertising creative.<a href="http://www.nikeshoxstyle.com" title="Nike shox shoes"> Nike shox shoes </a>

Rethardus 08-24-2010 11:16 AM

On animanga events, a lot of people wear lolita and cosplay, even though it's clearly not fit for them. In the cosplay department, a lot of them treat it as some sort of carnival, neglecting all the rules to cosplay and just do whatever they want (even though it means they fail).

As for lolita, you can't forbid someone to wear something, but you need to have self-knowledge. Nobody can forbid someone to put an underwear on its head and walk down the street, but if you have some common sense, you know it's ridiculous.

If you're overweight, just watch out with what you're wearing. You know that fashion is mean, and it's clearly not for yourself (people who say that are lying, or they don't realize that it's for other people). Fashion isn't for yourself, you're happy because you think it's beautiful. Beauty is something subjective, something that other people decide. For instance, the sense for beauty changes throughout the century. It doesn't make sense that people say they wear something, regardless of what other people think.

Because I haven't heard anyone who likes to wear underwear up its head as fashion. But I heard about people who like lolita, because they feel accepted in a lolita group, even though not in other fashion groups.

Dayanx 10-12-2010 12:30 AM

Besides the fashion industry aiming at presenting a waifishly thin image, in more stylized artwork, its a lot easier to draw thin people. I know because I've drawn both. Lolita as a style of art pretty much requires it, as the girls aren't presenting themselves as little girls as much as they are porcelain dolls. (IMO)

When cosplaying, I think one's body does play into it. This can be unfortunate for thicker people, darker skinned people, ect because there's just not really many characters to pick from.


Rakutenka 10-21-2010 08:02 PM

Everyone should do what they think makes them happy...!!!

_______________________________________________________________
If a person (nevermind the weight!!) dresses strange/revealingly in public they should be ble to deal with the consequences themselves .

(gossip, chitchat, being offended)

That includes gothic/lolita , cosplay and other out-of-the-ordinary styles (punks) as well........



=^___^=

yuujirou 10-21-2010 10:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NanteNa (Post 825347)
Haha, you'd be surprised how many girls actually dress up to impress one another spite to impress their boyfriends or guys in general ; D You can say that we keep each other fit. Haha!

oddly enough... i find myself doing that to girls sometimes >.<''
like... wearing shapes just to show off to other girls and to say that i, a guy, can pull off certain outfits better than they can =P
geez i'm spiteful >.>''

so to be on topic....

I'm fine w/ it as long as no one's committing a [fashion] crime :3
(look at my avatar =D)

CoolNard 10-22-2010 04:10 AM

Overweight girls have the right to wear lolita, or whatever they want; but let's be frank, they just don't have the privilege to look better than people whose physiques are more adaptable. Same goes for any other person.

LillyFields 10-22-2010 07:53 AM

I really think the chubby girls look so cute in Lolita wear. Little stumpy fingers, round eyes, pudgy legs, curly hair... they look so innocent & childlike, like a doll. More authentic.

You don't see skinny dolls do you ?

CoolNard 10-22-2010 09:08 AM

Haha, for some reason, I'm drawn amiably to your post. I take back what I said. Plump/chubby/flabby girls/guys may look nice in anything - lolita included. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. :rolleyes:

Suki 10-22-2010 11:19 AM

I'd say the Lolita style doesn't suit anyone. At all. Overweight or skinny, those girls would look much better in normal clothes. I don't get why people feel the need to tell the world how different and special they are by putting on weird clothing. Cause that's what it is, no offense. I agree everyone can wear whatever they want, but then again it's okay for people to judge them, because they moment they decide to go out in the streets looking that way, they know they'll get stares, and it's because they want to be judged and noticed that they do it. I don't mean it in a bad way, but it's obvious they wanna get people's attention, otherwise I don't get why they'd wanna dress that way. They might feel comfy and pretty and whatever else, but the fact that they choose to stand out from a crowd talks about who they are, and if you want people to notice that, you might a well be prepared to get stares.

Rakutenka 10-23-2010 09:56 PM

@Suki-san: great summary x3 ! THat's just how it is!


*gives cookies to everyonE*

greetz~
Raku,.

RealJames 11-04-2010 01:58 AM

Pull off the lolita style better?

not at all

Do you think overweight girls should just stop wearing lolita?

yes, but I also think the far too skinny girls also should stop

Do you think brand should be made in bigger sizes because thin girls don't look as good in it?

no, dear god please no for the sake of all men's eyes
unfortunately the super thin girls just buy the kid-versions and you can' t prevent it :(

a little chubby is best imo :)

boinky78 11-04-2010 04:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LillyFields (Post 834118)
I really think the chubby girls look so cute in Lolita wear. Little stumpy fingers, round eyes, pudgy legs, curly hair... they look so innocent & childlike, like a doll. More authentic.

You don't see skinny dolls do you ?

yea


tbh when i think childlike i think fragile little body
with a baby face
basicly a girl who looks like this


Quote:

Originally Posted by Suki (Post 834142)
I'd say the Lolita style doesn't suit anyone. At all. Overweight or skinny, those girls would look much better in normal clothes. I don't get why people feel the need to tell the world how different and special they are by putting on weird clothing. Cause that's what it is, no offense. I agree everyone can wear whatever they want, but then again it's okay for people to judge them, because they moment they decide to go out in the streets looking that way, they know they'll get stares, and it's because they want to be judged and noticed that they do it. I don't mean it in a bad way, but it's obvious they wanna get people's attention, otherwise I don't get why they'd wanna dress that way. They might feel comfy and pretty and whatever else, but the fact that they choose to stand out from a crowd talks about who they are, and if you want people to notice that, you might a well be prepared to get stares.

So because everyone doesnt wanna dress like you do you assume they want attention?
And here I thought thinking for yourself was a good thing
why would you want to dress boring if you can afford to look beautiful?

bobkerry 11-04-2010 09:16 PM

i think brands should be in bigger sizes too because i myself find sometime difficulty while shopping...so this should be there in order to release this tension

RealJames 11-05-2010 12:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boinky78 (Post 835864)
tbh when i think childlike i think fragile little body
with a baby face
basicly a girl who looks like this

If I am reading this correctly, you think overweight girls, or even a little fat, should not try to dress this way? Because they can't do the fragile little body look?

If that is what you are saying, I agree entirely!

xYinniex 11-05-2010 02:26 PM

=O PAEDO CONVENTION. Oh wait, sorry, that was a an easy mistake.

Look, honey, I know that we women regard youthfulness as this amazing life source, but think back to when you were 14? No one looked that amazing, in fact most of us were going through a spotty puberty phase, in addition to terrifying period cramps because you've just never felt pain like that before.

Suki 11-07-2010 01:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boinky78 (Post 835864)
So because everyone doesnt wanna dress like you do you assume they want attention?
And here I thought thinking for yourself was a good thing
why would you want to dress boring if you can afford to look beautiful?

Of course they seek attention. If they didn't want it, then why would they choose to dress in a way they know will get attention?

I'm not saying everyone should dress like me, I'm saying if they wanna be taken seriously, they shouldn't dress like they live in a world where everyday's dress up in a costume day. Period.

Dress boring...? So not getting yourself to look like you're about to entener some costume contest is boring. I can afford whatever I want, but I don't want to look like I'm stuck in the age of 10. And like I said, no girl looks better in Lolita clothes than they do in normal clothes. Unless, of course, they are dressing up. I suggest you go to a job interview looking like that, see how proud that makes you feel in that situation.

boinky78 11-08-2010 03:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Suki (Post 836317)
Of course they seek attention. If they didn't want it, then why would they choose to dress in a way they know will get attention?

I'm not saying everyone should dress like me, I'm saying if they wanna be taken seriously, they shouldn't dress like they live in a world where everyday's dress up in a costume day. Period.

Dress boring...? So not getting yourself to look like you're about to entener some costume contest is boring. I can afford whatever I want, but I don't want to look like I'm stuck in the age of 10. And like I said, no girl looks better in Lolita clothes than they do in normal clothes. Unless, of course, they are dressing up. I suggest you go to a job interview looking like that, see how proud that makes you feel in that situation.

I perfer lolita because i just like victorian/Rococo fashion
I like it because its doll like/elegant and not all of it looks "kiddish"
what about classic lolita?or gothic lolita?You're just thinking about sweet lolita
In the 1700s-1800s women wore clothes similar to classic lolita all the time
are you saying they all looked like 10 year olds?hell if you look a paintings of marie antoinette some of her dresses look a lot like the lolita dresses worn today
I dont like attention at all its just I find "normal clothes" boring to look at
and I wish there werent so many people with your mentality
so people could wear what they like w/o random people harassing them or
making weird comments

Suki 11-18-2010 12:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boinky78 (Post 836404)
I perfer lolita because i just like victorian/Rococo fashion
I like it because its doll like/elegant and not all of it looks "kiddish"
what about classic lolita?or gothic lolita?You're just thinking about sweet lolita
In the 1700s-1800s women wore clothes similar to classic lolita all the time
are you saying they all looked like 10 year olds?hell if you look a paintings of marie antoinette some of her dresses look a lot like the lolita dresses worn today
I dont like attention at all its just I find "normal clothes" boring to look at
and I wish there werent so many people with your mentality
so people could wear what they like w/o random people harassing them or
making weird comments

I'm not harassing anyone, I'm just giving out my opinion since this is the purpose of this thread. Since you are not a doll nor are you living in the 1700s-1800s, wearing this kind of clothes as a day-to-day outfit is a bit out of place, in my opinion. And clothes are not meant to be fun to look at. I'm not saying you all should stop wearing what you want to wear. What I'm saying is, you go around looking like you dressed up in a costume and never took it off. I would not want people to notice me cause of how I dress and make judgements. You wanna do it? Go ahead. But frankly, would you go to a job interview in those clothes? Do you really think you'd make a good first impression?

LolisanX 11-23-2010 06:19 AM

Bigger girls, when doing Lolita, imo, don't look as great as the thinner ones who do it. However, when a thinner girl does Decora, she doesn't look as good as the bigger ones who do Decora. Being that I can never be "thin", I just stick with what works for me. And if I ever do think about doing Lolita in the future, I've got some dieting to do. Haha.

markspencer 03-21-2011 10:05 AM

Well technically styles aren't limited to a certain body type because they're made in different sizes, however that's not to say that a certain body type looks better in certain styles or that a certain style was created for a certain body type. As far as Lolita go, i think it's usually the slimmer the easier it is to pull it off but I don't doubt those that aren't as skinny can also make it look cute and attractive.

xYinniex 03-22-2011 03:44 PM

I change my answer/

Healthy girls look good in anything, better than thinner or overweight girls.

End of.

visualkeito 03-23-2011 07:07 AM

i really dont think weight matters when clothing comes into play.
i think how confident someone is while wearing a certain style is all that matters.

monkeyninja42 03-23-2011 07:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MissMisa (Post 803532)
We all (well, most of us) know that some types of clothes suit us, while others don't.

Because of the vast range of Lolita styles, there is most likely something to suit everyone. And Lolita is not a restrictive fashion, it is very suitable for plus size or smaller girls because of the huge range of tailor made clothing. In the lolita world, comission of clothing is very common.

To be perfectly honest, I don't care how a person looks or dressed, I don't even care if they get it wrong in Lolita. I don't care if a big breasted lady wears and empire waist by mistake. As long as they enjoy it, and they feel pretty, then meh.

(Cosplay for me however is different, as I see it as a kind of art that has to be right/accurate, where as Lolita is a fashion. But that's subject to opinion. Lolita of course is an art too, and cosplay can be a fashion, but the two remain leaning towards one thing or another.)


Totally agree! Especially about the cosplay part. I say wear what you'll have fun in.

Although as a curvy girl, I tend to avoid anything with as many layers and bows as a lolita getup! Something with a bias-cut and a flattering neckline suits so much better!

Humpakistani 04-04-2011 05:58 AM

yes i think the lolita style is always better because i always prefer this style but only for the smart girls and in this style they always looks very beautiful and i love this style but not for the overweight girls


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:48 AM.

Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.0.0 RC6